top of page

Michter's 25 Year Bourbon Returns, First Time Since 2023

15 hours ago
3 min read

Updated: 31 minutes ago

Michter's 25 Year Bourbon

One of the rarest bottles in the Michter's lineup is coming back. Michter's 25 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon has not been released since 2023, and shipments to bars, restaurants and stores begin December 1. It comes in at 116.2 proof with a suggested retail price of $1,500, and Michter's own president calls it one of the rarest whiskeys the company ever releases.


Why This Return Matters


This is not a new whiskey. It is a returning release, and that is part of the appeal. It has not been released since 2023, which makes this return a notable event.


Master Distiller Dan McKee and Master of Maturation Andrea Wilson approved the release of this year's bottling.


The timing is also notable. Michter's has been named the World's Most Admired Whiskey by Drinks International's academy of global buyers, journalists, bartenders and whisky experts for a fourth consecutive year, and Michter's says it is the first whiskey to be named in four consecutive years. This is the kind of bottle that brand reputation gets built on.


Michter's 25 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Inside the Bottle


Michter's 25 Year is a Kentucky straight bourbon, which means it is aged in first use barrels, as bourbon requires. That is the tricky part, and Wilson says it takes an extraordinary amount of care, attention to detail and precision to age a bourbon this long.


Wilson's view is that there is no substitute for patience, and that care and precision let an older whiskey show balance rather than just age. President Joseph J. Magliocco says what he loves about this bottling is that it offers decades of flavor "without being overly oaked."


According to McKee, the selected barrels deliver stone fruits, raisins, toffee, cinnamon and sweet tobacco, among other notes. The proof is 116.2 (58.1% ABV). That is strong but not extreme for a bourbon this old, and a good reason to add a drop of water if you are sipping it.



The Story Behind Michter's


The Michter's name has a long Pennsylvania past. Near Schaefferstown, a distillery site has a documented history of spirit production going back to 1753, when Swiss Mennonite farmers John and Michael Shenk began distilling rye whiskey there. That site later operated as Bomberger's Distillery and then as Michter's Distillery.


The old distillery closed in 1989. Today's Michter's whiskeys are more recently introduced products that have no direct connection to the old distillery.


Today the brand is known for bourbon, rye, sour mash whiskey and American whiskey, with an emphasis on limited production and whiskeys aged to peak maturity. That philosophy shows in a bottle like this one, where waiting 25 years is the whole point.


Price, Proof and Availability


  • Official Name: Michter's 25 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon

  • Category: Kentucky straight bourbon

  • Age: 25 years

  • ABV/Proof: 58.1% ABV (116.2 proof)

  • Price (SRP): $1,500

  • US Availability: shipments to bars, restaurants and stores begin December 1, 2026; the states receiving it have not been announced, so check with your local retailer

  • Limited Edition: yes, extremely limited; last released in 2023


Did You Know?


  • The old Michter's distillery site in Pennsylvania was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1975 and declared a National Historic Landmark in 1980.

  • When it closed in 1989, it was the smallest commercial distiller in America.


Tonights Poison Take

Tonights Poison Take


At $1,500++ (If you get lucky or even find it), this is a bottle for serious collectors and special-occasion pourers, and Michter's has built its reputation on exactly this kind of patient, low-volume release. The draw is the promise of old-bourbon depth without the heavy oak that long aging can bring. Expect it to be hard to find, and expect bars that get an allocation to pour it by the glass for people who want a taste without the full price.


Bar Talk: Bourbon has to age in brand new oak barrels, which is why a 25 year old one is so hard to pull off.


Know a bourbon fan who has been waiting for this one to come back? Send them this post before December 1.


More on Tonights Poison



About the author: Jas Sawhney (Tonights Poison) has spent 18 years in the beverage alcohol industry and shares new releases, tastings and spirits news as @tonightspoison on Instagram, TikTok and YouTube.



Please enjoy responsibly.

Comments


Subscribe To Stay Informed

Thanks for submitting, Cheers!

  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • TikTok

Spirits Blog | TonightsPoison

©2026 by TonightsPoison

bottom of page